Leveraging Public-Private Partnerships for Sustainable and Equitable WASH Service Delivery in Hyderabad

Unlocking the Potential of Collaborative Approaches

The provision of safe and reliable water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) services is a critical challenge facing many urban centers in India, particularly in rapidly growing cities like Hyderabad. Addressing this challenge requires innovative solutions that harness the strengths of both the public and private sectors.

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have emerged as a promising model for enhancing WASH service delivery, offering the potential to leverage private sector expertise, financing, and operational efficiencies while maintaining public sector oversight and accountability. As Hyderabad navigates the complexities of expanding and upgrading its WASH infrastructure, a strategic approach to PPPs can unlock significant benefits for the city’s residents.

Assessing the WASH Landscape in Hyderabad

Hyderabad, the capital of Telangana state, is home to over 10 million people and has experienced rapid population growth in recent decades. This rapid urbanization has placed immense pressure on the city’s WASH systems, leading to persistent challenges:

• Uneven Access to Water and Sanitation: While the city has made progress in expanding piped water coverage, many low-income communities and informal settlements still lack access to safely managed water and sanitation services. Approximately 20% of the population relies on groundwater sources or private tankers, which can be unreliable and of poor quality.

• Aging and Overburdened Infrastructure: Hyderabad’s water supply and sewerage networks are aging, with significant portions dating back to the 1960s and 1970s. This has resulted in high rates of water leakage, frequent service disruptions, and inadequate wastewater treatment capacity.

• Environmental Degradation and Water Scarcity: Groundwater depletion, surface water pollution, and the impacts of climate change have exacerbated the city’s water scarcity challenges, threatening the long-term sustainability of WASH services.

• Governance and Institutional Fragmentation: WASH service delivery in Hyderabad involves multiple government agencies and departments, leading to coordination challenges and gaps in accountability.

To address these complex issues, the Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (HMWSSB) has recognized the need for a multi-stakeholder approach that leverages the strengths of both the public and private sectors. This has led to a growing focus on developing effective PPP models for WASH service delivery.

Harnessing the Power of Public-Private Partnerships

PPPs offer several key advantages that can help Hyderabad achieve its WASH development goals:

1. Improved Access and Coverage: Private sector participation can accelerate the expansion of water and sanitation networks, particularly in underserved areas, by tapping into private capital, technical expertise, and operational efficiencies.

2. Enhanced Service Quality and Reliability: Private operators often bring advanced management practices, advanced technologies, and a stronger focus on customer service, leading to improvements in water quality, pressure, and continuity of supply.

3. Increased Operational Efficiency: Private partners can introduce innovative solutions to reduce non-revenue water, improve revenue collection, and optimize operations and maintenance, thereby enhancing the financial and environmental sustainability of WASH services.

4. Strengthened Governance and Accountability: Well-designed PPP frameworks can enhance transparency, define clear roles and responsibilities, and establish robust performance monitoring and evaluation systems to ensure accountable service delivery.

5. Facilitated Access to Finance: Private sector participation can help unlock access to commercial financing, reducing the burden on public budgets and enabling much-needed investments in WASH infrastructure.

In Hyderabad, the HMWSSB has already taken steps to explore PPP models for WASH service delivery, with several successful pilot projects underway:

Case Study: Outsourcing of Operations and Maintenance in Hyderabad
In 2016, the HMWSSB launched a PPP project to outsource the operations and maintenance (O&M) of water supply and wastewater treatment services in two pilot zones covering over 600,000 customers. The private operator was responsible for tasks such as network maintenance, leak detection, customer metering, and service delivery monitoring. The project has resulted in improved water supply reliability, reduced non-revenue water, and enhanced customer satisfaction, demonstrating the potential of leveraging private sector expertise.

Case Study: Performance-Based Service Contracts for Fecal Sludge Management
Recognizing the need to improve the city’s sanitation services, the HMWSSB has piloted performance-based service contracts with private operators for the safe collection, transport, and treatment of fecal sludge from on-site sanitation systems. This approach has helped to increase coverage, ensure proper disposal, and strengthen the overall fecal sludge management value chain.

These successful pilot projects have provided valuable insights and lessons to guide the expansion of PPP models in Hyderabad’s WASH sector. However, to unlock the full potential of these collaborative approaches, the city must address several key challenges and considerations.

Overcoming Barriers and Ensuring Equitable Outcomes

While PPPs hold promise for improving WASH services in Hyderabad, their successful implementation requires careful planning and a strong emphasis on equity and inclusiveness. Some of the key challenges and considerations include:

1. Robust Regulatory and Institutional Framework: Establishing a clear and transparent regulatory environment, with well-defined roles, responsibilities, and performance standards for public and private partners, is crucial for the success of PPP projects. This includes strengthening the capacity of the HMWSSB and other relevant agencies to effectively oversee and monitor PPP contracts.

2. Affordability and Pro-Poor Targeting: Ensuring that WASH services remain affordable for low-income households is a critical concern. PPP contracts must include provisions for targeted subsidies, lifeline tariffs, and other mechanisms to safeguard access for the most vulnerable communities.

3. Community Engagement and Participation: Meaningful community engagement throughout the planning, implementation, and monitoring of PPP projects is essential to ensure that the needs and concerns of all stakeholders are addressed. This can include facilitating partnerships with community-based organizations and leveraging participatory planning approaches.

4. Environmental and Social Sustainability: PPP projects must prioritize environmental sustainability, including efficient water use, wastewater treatment, and climate resilience. Social sustainability, such as fair labor practices and gender-inclusive employment opportunities, must also be embedded in the design and implementation of these partnerships.

5. Capacity Building and Knowledge Sharing: Strengthening the technical and managerial capacities of public sector agencies, private operators, and community stakeholders is crucial for the successful implementation and long-term sustainability of PPP models. Facilitating knowledge exchange and learning from best practices can further enhance the effectiveness of these collaborations.

By addressing these challenges and considerations, Hyderabad can leverage PPPs to deliver sustainable, equitable, and resilient WASH services that improve the quality of life for all residents. This will require a concerted effort to align the interests of the public and private sectors, prioritize the needs of underserved communities, and foster a collaborative, transparent, and accountable ecosystem for WASH service delivery.

Conclusion: Towards a Sustainable and Inclusive WASH Future

The experiences and lessons from Hyderabad’s PPP initiatives in the WASH sector offer valuable insights for other cities in India and beyond. By striking the right balance between public oversight and private sector dynamism, Hyderabad can harness the power of collaborative approaches to address its pressing WASH challenges and pave the way for a more sustainable and inclusive urban future.

As the city continues to evolve, the successful scaling up and replication of these PPP models will be crucial in ensuring that all residents, regardless of their socioeconomic status, have access to safe, reliable, and affordable WASH services. Through ongoing innovation, robust governance, and a steadfast commitment to equity, Hyderabad can become a shining example of how public-private partnerships can drive transformative change in the WASH sector.

https://jointactionforwater.org/