Understanding Virus Stability in Onsite Sanitation Systems
Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) has emerged as a powerful tool for public health monitoring, expanding its focus beyond enteric pathogens to include prevalent diseases with significant global impact. However, existing surveillance systems primarily concentrate on sewer-based infrastructure, excluding the 2.7 billion people worldwide who rely on non-sewered sanitation systems.
To address this gap, a recent study explored the potential of fecal sludge treatment plants (FSTPs) as a strategic sampling point for WBE. The persistence of viral RNA targets, including SARS-CoV-2, human norovirus (HuNoV), and microbial source trackers (MSTs) like pepper mild mottle virus (PMMoV) and tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), was examined in fecal sludge samples from a centralized treatment facility in Dakar, Senegal.
Key Findings:
- High Viral Persistence: The study revealed exceptional stability of viral targets in fecal sludge, with T90 values (time required for 90% reduction) of 3.3 months for SARS-CoV-2 N1 and N2, and 6.2 months for ToBRFV, even under various temperature conditions (4°C, 15°C, and 30°C).
- Limited Decay: All viral targets persisted throughout the 70-day experiment, with less than 1 log10 reduction observed, indicating minimal decay under the tested conditions.
- Comparable Abundance of Novel MST: The newly introduced MST, ToBRFV, exhibited comparable abundance to the well-established PMMoV in fecal sludge, suggesting its potential as an alternative marker.
These findings address a crucial gap in understanding virus persistence in onsite sanitation systems, providing essential decay rate constants to facilitate effective viral target detection. The remarkable stability of viruses in fecal sludge highlights the potential of FSTPs as a centralized sampling location for localized pathogen surveillance, particularly in low-income settings where non-sewered sanitation is prevalent.
Leveraging Fecal Sludge Treatment Plants for Wastewater-Based Epidemiology
Traditionally, WBE has relied on sewer-based infrastructure for sampling and analysis. However, this approach excludes a significant proportion of the global population that utilizes on-site sanitation systems, such as septic tanks and pit latrines. By exploring the potential of FSTPs, this study offers a strategic solution to expand the reach of WBE for comprehensive public health monitoring.
Advantages of FSTPs for WBE:
-
Centralized Sampling Location: Fecal sludge treatment plants serve as a centralized point for collecting samples from numerous on-site sanitation systems, enabling efficient and representative sampling.
-
Virus Persistence: The demonstrated high persistence of viral targets in fecal sludge, even at elevated temperatures, ensures the stability of biomarkers for effective detection and surveillance.
-
Broader Representation: Sampling at FSTPs provides a more inclusive snapshot of the community’s health status, capturing populations relying on non-sewered sanitation systems that are often overlooked in traditional sewer-based WBE.
-
Feasibility in Low-Resource Settings: The centralized nature of FSTPs and the proven stability of viral targets make this approach particularly well-suited for implementation in low-income settings, where on-site sanitation systems are more prevalent.
By leveraging the strategic advantages of FSTPs, WBE can extend its reach and enhance public health monitoring, particularly in areas where sewer-based infrastructure is limited. This innovative approach holds the potential to inform targeted interventions and facilitate more comprehensive disease surveillance, ultimately improving community health outcomes.
Advancing Viral Persistence Research in Onsite Sanitation
The findings from this study contribute to a growing body of knowledge on the fate and behavior of viruses in onsite sanitation systems. Understanding virus persistence is crucial for evaluating the potential risks associated with exposure and for informing effective treatment and management strategies.
Key Insights on Viral Persistence:
-
Temperature Resilience: The exceptional stability of viral targets, such as SARS-CoV-2 and HuNoV, across a range of temperatures (4°C, 15°C, and 30°C) highlights their ability to withstand various environmental conditions encountered in on-site sanitation systems.
-
Minimal Decay: The observed limited decay (less than 1 log10 reduction) of all viral targets over the 70-day experiment underscores the persistent nature of these pathogens in fecal sludge, even in the absence of ideal replication conditions.
-
Implications for Surveillance: The high persistence of viruses in fecal sludge suggests that centralized FSTPs can serve as strategic sampling points for effective pathogen surveillance, particularly in resource-limited settings where on-site sanitation is more prevalent.
-
Significance of Microbial Source Trackers: The comparable abundance of the novel MST, ToBRFV, to the well-established PMMoV highlights the potential of alternative viral markers for source tracking and water quality assessment in onsite sanitation systems.
These insights contribute to a deeper understanding of virus behavior in the context of on-site sanitation, informing the development of more comprehensive and targeted monitoring and management strategies. By leveraging the strategic advantages of FSTPs, public health authorities can strengthen their ability to detect and respond to emerging infectious disease threats, ultimately safeguarding community wellbeing.
Conclusion: Unlocking the Potential of Fecal Sludge for Improved Public Health Surveillance
The persistence of respiratory, enteric, and fecal indicator viruses in fecal sludge presents a unique opportunity to enhance wastewater-based epidemiology and improve public health monitoring, particularly in low-income settings where on-site sanitation systems prevail.
By exploring the stability of viral biomarkers in fecal sludge, this study has demonstrated the strategic value of FSTPs as centralized sampling locations to capture a more inclusive representation of community health status. The exceptional persistence of viruses, such as SARS-CoV-2 and HuNoV, underscores the potential of this approach to facilitate effective pathogen surveillance and inform targeted interventions.
Moreover, the introduction of the novel microbial source tracker, ToBRFV, as a viable alternative to the well-established PMMoV highlights the continued evolution of tools for water quality assessment and source tracking in onsite sanitation systems.
As the world grapples with emerging infectious diseases and the ongoing challenge of ensuring equitable access to safe water and sanitation, the insights gained from this study can inform the development of more comprehensive and inclusive public health monitoring frameworks. By leveraging the strategic advantages of FSTPs, researchers and practitioners can unlock the potential of fecal sludge to strengthen disease surveillance, protect vulnerable communities, and advance sustainable development goals.
